Western New York

• 1991 Detective Sergeant Joseph A. LaRosa, Hamburg Police Department
• 1992 Officer Lawrence J. Metlak, Buffalo Police Department
• 1993 Officer Victor A. DeSimone, Buffalo Police Department
• 1994 Officer Robert Quintana, Buffalo Police Department
• 1995 Lieutenant Albert Damiani, Buffalo Police Department
• 1996 Lieutenant Kenneth M. Bienko, Buffalo Police Department
• 1997 Detective Vincent Pupo, Jr., Erie County Sheriff
• 1998 Deputy David R. Carlson, Erie County Sheriff
• 1999 Officer Michael N. Martinez, Buffalo Police Department
• 2000 Officer Gregory Handgis, Buffalo Police Department
• 2002 Trooper John C. Morrow, New York State Police
• 2003 Detective Sergeant Michael N. Torrillo, New York State Police
• 2004 NYS Trooper Monte A. Trimble, New York State Police
• 2006 Lieutenant Joseph A. Buccilli, Orchard Park Police Department
• 2007 K-9 Officer Steven D. Ritchie, Lockport Police Department
• 2008 Trooper Michael J. Niezgoda, Jr., New York State Police
  
• 2010 Trooper John M. Spero, New York State Police
• 2011 Lieutenant Cheryl Rucinski of the Cheektowaga Police Department
• 2012 Lieutenant David Schuman, Cattaraugus County Sheriff’s Office
  
• 2016 Captain Eric L. Laughton
• 2017 Officer Michael Hoffman
• 2018 Trooper Sean Pierce
• 2025 Deputy Brandon Radoani